Dr. Craigie’s research focuses on how people with mental disabilities make decisions, ensuring they have the support they need without being unduly influenced by others. He looks at various aspects of mental capacity, investigating how legal systems can change to better support these individuals in making informed choices about their lives, health, and finances. Dr. Craigie's studies often highlight the rights of individuals facing challenges in decision-making, including those with conditions like alcohol dependence and anorexia nervosa. His findings aim to improve laws, treatment approaches, and the ethical considerations surrounding patient autonomy in mental health and legal contexts.
Key findings
In a review of 40 resources on decision-making support, Dr. Craigie found a significant lack of guidance in England, particularly for those with decision-making difficulties.
He introduced six different ways to understand 'undue influence' in decision-making, which can help shape better policies for individuals with mental disabilities.
Dr. Craigie's research revealed that interpretations of mental incapacity tests for alcohol dependence and anorexia nervosa can lead to different treatment decisions, impacting fairness in assessments.
Frequently asked questions
Does Dr. Craigie study decision-making in people with mental disabilities?
Yes, he focuses on how to support people with mental disabilities in making informed decisions about their legal rights, health, and finances.
What treatments has Dr. Craigie researched?
He has researched how decision-making support can improve treatment outcomes for individuals with conditions like alcohol dependence and anorexia nervosa.
Is Dr. Craigie's work relevant to caregivers of patients with mental disabilities?
Absolutely, his research provides insights that can help caregivers support their loved ones in making their own decisions.
How does Dr. Craigie's work affect laws regarding mental capacity?
His findings advocate for changes in laws to better protect the decision-making rights of individuals with mental disabilities.
What impact does Dr. Craigie's work have on patient autonomy?
His research promotes a better understanding of how to balance patient autonomy with the necessary support to ensure safe decision-making.
Publications in plain English
Support for decision-making guidance in England: a pragmatic review.
2025
Medical law review
Craigie J, Alley A, Cotrufo MT, Bach M, Rawles J +3 more
Plain English This study looked at how support for decision-making (SFDM) is understood and used in England, especially for adults who might struggle with making choices. Researchers reviewed 40 resources on SFDM and found that there is a lack of clear guidance, particularly on how different types of decisions and individual relationships affect the support given. The findings highlight the need for better, more comprehensive guidance that aligns with international standards, which would help clarify how to assist people in making their own decisions while respecting their legal rights.
Who this helps: This benefits adults with decision-making difficulties, caregivers, and mental health professionals.
Conceptualising 'Undue Influence' in Decision-Making Support for People with Mental Disabilities.
2021
Medical law review
Craigie J
Plain English This study looked at how to understand "undue influence" when supporting people with mental disabilities in making decisions related to their legal rights, such as property and healthcare. Researchers found six different ways to think about undue influence, with one new idea focusing on how vulnerable people might be overpowered in decision-making. This matters because it can help shape better laws and policies, ensuring that individuals with mental disabilities are supported without being pressured into choices they might not fully understand.
Who this helps: This helps individuals with mental disabilities and the professionals who support them.
Problems of Control: Alcohol Dependence, Anorexia Nervosa, and the Flexible Interpretation of Mental Incapacity Tests.
2019
Medical law review
Craigie J, Davies A
Plain English This study looked at how mental incapacity tests evaluate individuals who struggle with alcohol dependence compared to those with anorexia nervosa in England and Wales. It found that both types of tests can account for issues of control, but the way they are interpreted can lead to different outcomes. For example, the interpretation of these tests can significantly affect decisions about treatment and legal responsibility, which raises concerns about fairness in these assessments.
Who this helps: This helps patients struggling with alcohol dependence and their doctors when it comes to making treatment decisions.
Legal capacity, mental capacity and supported decision-making: Report from a panel event.
2019
International journal of law and psychiatry
Craigie J, Bach M, Gurbai S, Kanter A, Kim SYH +2 more
Plain English This study examined the ongoing conversation about legal capacity and mental capacity for people with disabilities, focusing on how supported decision-making can help them. The panel discussions revealed disagreements on how limiting legal capacity affects those with mental disabilities and how to properly assess their mental capacity. Understanding these issues is crucial because they impact the rights and freedoms of people with disabilities, especially regarding their ability to make decisions about their own lives.
Who this helps: This benefits individuals with mental disabilities and their advocates.
A Fine Balance: Reconsidering Patient Autonomy in Light of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
2015
Bioethics
Craigie J
Plain English The study looks at how the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities is changing the way we think about patient autonomy in mental health. It finds that while the Convention supports patients in making their own decisions, it also creates some confusion about how to balance patients' freedom with the need for support. This matters because it highlights challenges in applying these principles fairly in real-life situations.
Who this helps: This helps patients with disabilities and mental health issues.
Against a singular understanding of legal capacity: Criminal responsibility and the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
2015
International journal of law and psychiatry
Craigie J
Plain English This research paper examines how the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities impacts the legal rights of people with mental disabilities, particularly in relation to criminal responsibility. It argues that personal decision-making and criminal acts should not be treated the same way under the law, as different moral and political standards apply to these situations. The findings raise important questions about how legal capacity is defined and underscore the need for careful consideration of these standards when discussing rights for individuals with mental disabilities.
Who this helps: This helps individuals with mental disabilities and their advocates.
Rates of exponential decay in systems of discrete energy levels by Stieltjes imaging.
2014
The Journal of chemical physics
Craigie J, Hammad A, Cooper B, Averbukh V
Plain English Researchers studied how certain energy levels in molecules decay over time, focusing on a specific technique called Stieltjes imaging. They found that this method effectively calculates decay rates, showing that in a molecule called trans-butadiene, a particular process can disrupt traditional views of how energy levels behave during molecular ionization. This matters because it improves our understanding of molecular behavior, which can be important for fields like chemistry and materials science.
Who this helps: This helps scientists and researchers studying molecular interactions and energy transitions.
Capacity, value neutrality and the ability to consider the future.
2013
International journal of law in context
Craigie J
Plain English This research looks at how laws related to mental capacity should apply to everyone, including those with mental health issues. It found that existing laws, like the Mental Capacity Act 2005, are designed to protect patient choices, but using a long-term view on mental capacity can actually weaken these protections. This is important because it raises ethical questions about how to best respect individuals' rights while ensuring their safety.
Who this helps: This benefits patients with mental health issues and their advocates.
Competence, practical rationality and what a patient values.
2011
Bioethics
Craigie J
Plain English This study examined the balance between patient autonomy and the need to intervene when a patient is judged not competent to make treatment decisions, focusing on patients with anorexia who refuse care. The author argues that, in these cases, we should consider the reasoning behind their decisions and how it aligns with practical decision-making principles. This matters because it could provide a clearer way to justify when involuntary treatment is necessary to protect vulnerable patients.
Who this helps: This helps patients with anorexia and the doctors treating them.
Simultaneous bilateral breast reconstruction with in-the-crease inferior gluteal artery perforator flaps.
2009
Annals of plastic surgery
Levine JL, Miller Q, Vasile J, Khoobehi K, Craigie J +2 more
Plain English This study looked at a specific method for breast reconstruction using tissue from the buttocks in patients who didn't have enough tissue from their abdomen. Researchers operated on 22 women at the same time, successfully performing surgery on both breasts, with no flap failures and a 100% survival rate for the tissue used. Some patients had minor complications, but most were happy with the results and recovery.
Who this helps: This helps women undergoing breast reconstruction who may not have enough abdominal tissue available.
Hopping, skipping or jumping to conclusions? Clarifying the role of the JTC bias in delusions.
2007
Cognitive neuropsychiatry
Fine C, Gardner M, Craigie J, Gold I
Plain English This study looked at a thinking pattern called "jumping to conclusions" (JTC) that is common in people with delusions. Researchers analyzed various studies and found that people with delusions often made decisions based on less evidence than those without delusions, particularly in a task where they had to judge the likelihood of seeing different colored beads. This matters because understanding the JTC bias can help address how delusions form and persist, which is important for improving treatments for those affected.
Who this helps: This helps patients with delusions and their healthcare providers.
An investigation of the effectiveness of police cruiser doors as protection from handgun attack.
2005
International journal of occupational safety and ergonomics : JOSE
Fogleman M, Craigie J, Stobbe T
Plain English This study looked at how well police cruiser doors can protect officers from handgun attacks. The researchers found that 68% of the bullets fired at the doors went through, indicating that these doors offer limited protection. This is important because it highlights the need for better safety measures for officers when they encounter gunfire on duty.
Who this helps: This helps police officers by informing safety equipment standards and protective measures.
Novel hexad repeats conserved in a putative transporter with restricted expression in cell types associated with growth, calcium exchange and homeostasis.
2004
Experimental cell research
Brasier G, Tikellis C, Xuereb L, Craigie J, Casley D +5 more
Plain English Researchers studied a transport protein that helps move calcium in and out of cells, with specific focus on its role in growth and calcium balance in the body. They found that this protein is mostly active in certain cells, like those in the pituitary gland, which produce hormones for growth and lactation, as well as in developing bone and kidney cells. The findings show that this protein is crucial for managing calcium levels, which is important for body growth and health.
Who this helps: Patients needing better management of growth and calcium-related conditions.
Plain English This paper looks at pharmacogenomics, a technology from the Human Genome Project that studies how genes affect a person's response to drugs. The authors highlight ethical issues, such as fairness in drug trials for small or "orphan" populations and the need for informed consent when using genetic testing. These discussions are important as they can shape how drugs are developed and used, ensuring that everyone gets the best possible treatment.
Who this helps: This helps patients and doctors by promoting fairer and more effective drug treatments.
STUDIES ON THE SOLUBLE PRECIPITABLE SUBSTANCES OF VACCINIA : I. THE DISSOCIATION IN VITRO OF SOLUBLE PRECIPITABLE SUBSTANCES FROM ELEMENTARY BODIES OF VACCINIA.
1936
The Journal of experimental medicine
Craigie J, Wishart FO
Plain English This study looked at certain substances that can be separated from small virus particles related to the vaccinia vaccine, which is used against smallpox. Researchers found that both heat-sensitive and heat-stable forms of these substances can be isolated from the virus and are similar to those found in the actual vaccine. This matters because understanding these components can improve vaccine quality and efficacy.
Who this helps: This helps patients who receive the smallpox vaccine.
STUDIES ON THE SOLUBLE PRECIPITABLE SUBSTANCES OF VACCINIA : II. THE SOLUBLE PRECIPITABLE SUBSTANCES OF DERMAL VACCINE.
1936
The Journal of experimental medicine
Craigie J, Wishart FO
Plain English This study looked at two types of substances in a smallpox vaccine: thermolabile (L) and thermostable (S) antigens. Researchers found that both types of antigens are found in the vaccine and play a role in how the immune system reacts to the vaccine. Understanding these components helps improve the effectiveness of vaccinations against smallpox and related viruses.
Who this helps: This benefits patients receiving smallpox vaccination and healthcare providers involved in vaccination efforts.
STUDIES ON THE SOLUBLE PRECIPITABLE SUBSTANCES OF VACCINIA : III. THE PRECIPITIN RESPONSES OF RABBITS TO THE LS ANTIGEN OF VACCINIA.
1936
The Journal of experimental medicine
Wishart FO, Craigie J
Plain English This study focused on how rabbits’ immune systems respond to a specific part of the vaccinia virus called the LS antigen. Researchers found that this antigen triggers the production of two types of antibodies, L and S, even when it's purified or dissolved. Specifically, the L antibodies lose their effectiveness after being heated to 70 degrees Celsius, while the S antibodies can still provoke an immune response even after heating to 90 degrees Celsius.
Who this helps: This information benefits vaccine developers and researchers working on improving virus vaccines.
F O Wishart Michael Bach Kamran Khoobehi Robert J Allen Antonia Alley Maria Teresa Cotrufo Jodie Rawles Isabel C H Clare Matt Matravers Francesca Happé
Physician data sourced from the
NPPES NPI Registry
.
Publication data from
PubMed
.
Plain-English summaries generated by AI.
Not medical advice.